Every objection we know of, and where each one is answered
In the words people use to make them. Each one is answered on the page it attacks, next to the claim it is aimed at, rather than gathered here away from it. This page is the index.
Where the paper has an answer, you get it. Where it does not, the objection is listed with the open questions and says so.
22 OBJECTIONS
The index
-
What a block reward buys
-
A proof-of-work chain that admits its own proof of work is pointless.
-
-
What is being claimed, and what is not
-
Paying miners to abandon Bitcoin and calling it research.
-
It's an ADA pump in a Bitcoin costume.
-
-
Who did this first, and what is new here
-
This is 0xBitcoin with extra steps. Or TUNA with a Bitcoin header.
-
Citing IOG's own research to argue for a Cardano token — that's grading your own homework.
-
-
How a WHAT comes into existence
-
Minting only through the validator — fine, but who deployed the validator, and what did they mint while nobody was looking?
-
-
How many there will ever be
-
21 million and halvings. Three lines of code and a Bitcoin cover version.
-
-
Mining from genesis is not a premine
-
Mining from genesis on a chain whose difficulty starts at nothing is a premine with extra steps.
-
-
Why mining eventually stops
-
Mining stops by design. You've shipped abandonware and written the date on the box.
-
-
What a large fleet gets by turning up
-
A whale shows up on day one and takes the entire early issuance.
-
-
Why a difficulty below 1 is legitimate
-
Difficulty below 1 means nobody is mining it and the chain is dead.
-
-
Mine
-
Mining before genesis is an insider head start whatever you call it.
-
You said finality is Cardano's, then you said the tip reverts. Pick one.
-
A hot wallet signs every block and there's a reference pool from day one. That's a central point of failure.
-
-
Pool, solo, and running an endpoint
-
Pool fees aren't verifiable. You've built a trust-me layer on a trustless chain.
-
-
How to get WHAT without mining
-
No way to buy it, no exchange, no liquidity. So it's unbuyable and the price question is unanswerable anyway.
-
-
What a hash spent here costs you
-
Paying hashpower to leave Bitcoin is an attack on Bitcoin's security budget dressed up as research.
-
-
How the hashprice figure is computed
-
A week is a convenient bound. Why not a day?
-
-
Where arriving hashpower came from
-
You can't tell migrated hashpower from revived, or from somebody's new rig. So the measurement measures nothing.
-
-
How fast a catch-up can run
-
If blocks can chain inside one Cardano block, a fleet can mint a burst of them in seconds.
-
-
How to tell a real WHAT from an imitation
-
No policy ID. ‘Verify it yourself’ with half the inputs missing.
Read the answer on How to tell a real WHAT from an imitation
-
-
Why the rules cannot change
-
Who can change the validator? Because somebody always can.
-