Why a difficulty below 1 is legitimate here

DifficultyHow much work a block currently takes, quoted as a ratio against Bitcoin's difficulty-1 target. is quoted here the way it is quoted everywhere, so a chain with little hashpower behind it sits legitimately below 1. On this chain that is a working state rather than a broken one.

Bitcoin stops at difficulty 1 because it has to. Its only clock is its own accumulated work, so if blocks became free it would have no clock at all. WHAT takes its time from Cardano and pays from a schedule counted in blocks, so the block rate is held by the rule rather than by what a hash costs.

whitepaper §6

A floor would not prevent cheap blocks. It would prevent mining.

A lone CPU mints at roughly ten-minute spacing whatever the target, and loses that the moment anyone else arrives, because the base tightens under it on every block. So the cheap blocks are self-correcting already.

Putting a floor at difficulty 1 would not stop them. It would hold the allowed target above what the hashpower actually present can meet — which is exactly the case this chain exists to serve. A quiet chain with a floor does not produce expensive blocks; it produces no blocks, and the thing the chain was built to show goes unrecorded.

The ceiling is instead the header format's: a full-width nBitsThe four bytes of a header that state the target the miner is committing to; the easiest value this chain allows is 0x7fffff · 2²³², a full-width mantissa at the loosest exponent that stays inside a 256-bit target. mantissa at the loosest exponent that does not run past the 256-bit hash itself — about two hashes a block. That is where the loosening stops, and difficulty 1 has nothing to do with it.

Loosening ceiling
0x7fffff · 2232 A full-width nBits mantissa at the loosest exponent that stays inside a 256-bit hash — about two hashes a block.
Quoted difficulty at that ceiling
far below 1 A ratio against Bitcoin's difficulty-1 target, and a legitimate figure for a chain nobody is mining hard.

whitepaper §9

What a difficulty below 1 is telling you

It is telling you how much hashpower is here, which is the number this chain exists to publish. A low one is an answer in the same way a high one would be, and the design treats them the same on purpose.

Which brings up the number that decides whether anybody points a rig at this at all: what a hash is worth here.